MLP Trade Reaction – Kyle Yates and Susannah Barr Headline 4-Player Trade

📸 @darkhorse_pb

Another trade in Major League Pickleball (MLP) was announced today as teams are clearly looking to make things happen and know they have to go for it if they want to win. The Hard 8s traded Susannah Barr and John Cincola to the Bus for Kyle Yates and Milan Rane.

It’s a very interesting trade as both teams tried to address a real need – the Hard 8s with their #2 male and the Bus with their #2 female. We have really hammered home the point that the Hard 8s needed to do something about Cincola and they end up with a significant upgrade, but it also comes at a steep price to lose Susannah Barr. The biggest advantage the Hard 8s had as a team is they had two top half women by getting Barr as a steal at the #18 spot. Really, it seems to us that the move for the Hard 8s puts them in a similar predicament, except now they have a two strong men instead of two strong women. You know what they say, when one door closes, another one opens, or something like that.

Daescu and Yates will be a natural fit together as a duo who have played together recently. However, Rane and Yates did not form a particularly strong mixed team in Newport and neither of their mixed results outside of MLP separate are encouraging for them as well. Rane was picked right at the end of the initial draft and it still feels right that she is borderline draftable for MLP. If it weren’t for her close relationship to Jorja Johnson, we would think the play would be to drop her and try to upgrade that spot the waiver wire, especially if the expectation is that there are going to be a number women dropped by other teams. For Yates, he has figured out his place in pickleball as a high end, right-sided guy this year, but the mixed results have continued to trend down. As much as an upgrade as Yates is for the Hard 8s on the men’s side, the resulting downgrade on the women’s side is more significant in our view. It appears the intention is in the right place for improvement for the Hard 8s but it’s difficult to picture to see how this trade improves their standing in the MLP landscape.

Moving over to the Bus, this is a win for them. The Bus did not make the playoffs in Austin or Newport, and now only have one player remaining from their drafted team. They get to pair Lauren Stratman with Susannah Barr and, much like the Hard 8s previous situation, that should be a lethal women’s pairing that rivels that Bright/Kawamoto partnership. The question for the Bus is going to be how this team fares in men’s and for their #2 mixed team. Wes Burrows proved he can get wins with Lauren Stratman against opposing #1 mixed teams, but Cincola did not have a lot of success with either Daescu or Barr. It seems unlikely Cincola would have success with Wes Burrows, who is a weaker men’s doubles player than Daescu.

While both teams are getting upgrades at different spots in this trade, we also think that the weaker player going both ways in the transaction are droppable. If the Bus decide to drop Cincola, there are a number of guys who could fit in with this group that would make them a scary out for any team. Gabe Tardio, Ben Newell and, even former Bus member, Eden Lica are all very viable options. There may not be a ton of consistency in a Burrows/Tardio partnership, but we wouldn’t want to be on the other side of those matchups in a winner take all elimination match. It’s unclear if the Bus can put it all together for an entire event with their roster, but they are one move away from being a scary out.

Ultimately, it’s good to see that teams are understanding where their place is in MLP and they are willing to take some risks in an attempt to better their roster. Even though we think there is a winner and a loser to this trade, both teams looked in the mirror, identified their problem and worked out something creative to try to fix it. This is the last event of the year so if it doesn’t work out you start again next year. We’ll be curious if MLP switches to a dynasty model rather than re-drafting each year as that comes with its own pros and cons. Either way, it’s clear that teams are playing for keeps and there should be more moves on the horizon.

Agree or disagree? Let us know in the comments below or email us at nmlpickleball@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook too!

9 thoughts on “MLP Trade Reaction – Kyle Yates and Susannah Barr Headline 4-Player Trade

  • August 25, 2022 at 9:13 am
    Permalink

    I’m confused about terms. Is waive and drop the same thing? “Waive” sounds friendlier. So when MLP talks about the waiver wire, does it mean a team dropped a player and will draft from the pool (based on positioning rules)?

    Reply
    • August 25, 2022 at 11:01 am
      Permalink

      Waive and drop is the same term, and yes it means that they would then select a player from the available player pool, which will include the dropped/waived players

      Reply
  • August 25, 2022 at 11:48 am
    Permalink

    Even though Barr was a hell of a #18 pick, the Hard 8’s made arguably the best trade of this MLP season.

    With one match to go, Milly is a big upgrade to Barr. Milly has a predictable style that can quickly mesh with the other team members. She also has a higher singles acumen. Barr has been slumping the last few tournaments and there’s no guarantee she’ll get out of it come Columbus.

    With the Cincola/Yates swap as well this could potentially be the biggest trade sabotage of the season.

    Reply
    • August 25, 2022 at 12:08 pm
      Permalink

      Barr just got bronze last week at the PPA’s Tournament of Champions, beating Catherine and Lea, Irina and Yana, and Jessie and Anna. Not sure I’d call that slumping. I’m sorry but there is no way that Millie is an upgrade from Susannah.

      Reply
      • August 25, 2022 at 12:47 pm
        Permalink

        Denise beat us to the response here but this 100% correct. Susannah and Viv beat Yana/Irina, Jessie/Anna, Catherine/Lea and their only loss was a tight match against the Waters. There are a handful of women out there who can get those results. Not sure what Rane’s best win or result is off the top of my head, but not even sure Rane has a pro podium. Almost certainly not in doubles

        Reply
        • August 25, 2022 at 3:10 pm
          Permalink

          Rane and Jorja got bronze at APP South Carolina. Bright/Oshiro got gold. Esquivel/Goldberg silver.

          Reply
          • August 25, 2022 at 3:34 pm
            Permalink

            See, this is what we need Jan! We were doing our draft and both forgot about that bronze for Milan

  • August 25, 2022 at 1:17 pm
    Permalink

    The Hard Eights undoubtedly upgraded on the men’s side and got weaker on the women’s. But it could get very interesting depending on what the H8’s do with Rane. Because of the strong left sided player that is Jorja, they could waive Rane and look for a consistent right side specialist. They couldn’t get the likes of Vivienne David, but even a C Carr could be interesting because she would be paired with a strong left sided in Jorja and a long left sided player in Daescu.

    Reply
  • Pingback: Major League Pickleball (MLP) Columbus – 5 Takeaways – Irina and Parris Reign Supreme – NML Pickleball

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *